This is not a strategic analysis. I have little data on what these players get paid, when their contracts end, how much attention they would attract from other clubs, or what the free agent market might look like. But I do know what it will take for me to start watching Cubs games with interest again. So take this only for what it is — the casual musings from the perspective of a life-long fan.
5. Phil Nevin
He came in to cover for Derrek Lee and has done well in the power department, but he’s of no use to us any longer and Walker will be fine at first for the rest of the season while Lee’s wrist heals. Trade him for a prospect of any caliber. No hard feelings.
4. Rich Hill
He’s “the best pitcher in AAA,” and in his last start in Chicago he lasted a full 3.1 innings while giving up only six hits, four runs, a homerun and three walks. Yes, that’s sarcasm. You still think he’s good? Fine, take him, and give me another Angel Pagan.
3. Jacque Jones
Yes, it turns out I was wrong about the Jones trade. He’s certainly outperformed Jeromy Burnitz this season. After being hitless in his first four games with the Cubs (and in seven of his first eight), Jones has slowly battled his way up to a solid .288 AVG. Over the last few months, he’s looked better than he has in years. Can you believe he’s got the second best average on the team? I’d say it’s time to sell high.
2. Mark Prior
When does his contract end? Whenever it is, be it at the end of this season or through 2010, we need to dump the guy. Prior and Wood are at the root of this current funk. I don’t care what you can get for him… he just needs to be out of the equation entirely. And after pitching five scoreless innings earlier this week, the time is ripe.
1. Juan Pierre
I know we have a one-year contract with Pierre. And I’m glad to see his average and on-base percentage rise from their low (low, low, low) points bottoming out in mid-May. It would have been nice to have this player around during the first half of the season, but he’s of absolutely no use to us in the second half. Maybe we can trade him for some decent pitching prospects… you know, like the one’s we gave up in exchange for him in the first place.
1060 West has a much more informed take on potential trades the Cubs could make, but it looks like the writer wants to get rid of some of our best guys. I guess that’s the point, but personally I wouldn’t trade Aramis Ramirez for anyone short of A-Rod, because you just know AramRam is going to be awesome as soon as he leaves (Nomar, anyone?). And I wouldn’t give the heave-ho to Michael Barrett, Scott Eyre or Bobby Howry, either; I would build next year’s team around those guys. I would also keep Greg Maddux around through the rest of this season for sentimental reasons, then hand him Bob Brenly’s job as the WGN color guy.
You gotta love the coinage of “Sir Toothpick McDoubleswitch,” though.